Under the kitchen sink in an Ontario home, a disposal is the one appliance that gets abused daily and noticed only when it quits. Maybe it hums and won't spin. Maybe it spits water onto the cabinet floor. Book through us and a plumber comes out to trace the cause, then puts a price on the cure, whether that means a reset, a new seal or a whole unit. Shower trouble goes through the same door, so it's covered below. To start, ask for a quote or return to the Chaffey Pipe and Drain home page.
What is wrong when a garbage disposal hums but won't turn?
A hum with no spin almost always means the grinding plate is jammed by something hard: a chicken bone, an avocado stone, a cap off a bottle, even a teaspoon. The motor is trying to turn and can't. Kill the switch first, and keep your hands well clear of the opening, because the blades can move without warning.
Flip the unit's belly toward you and you'll find a six-sided socket at the center. The plumber turns a hex key in that socket and works the plate back and forth until it frees. Next, press the red reset nub on the casing. It pops out whenever the motor overheats.
If it still hums after both steps, the problem is deeper: a seized bearing, a burnt winding or a worn flywheel. That is when repair stops paying. This Old House notes that disposals usually last about ten years and that repair only makes sense while the motor still runs.
Mend it or swap it: how to choose?
Mend it when the motor still spins freely and the fault is a jam, a leaking gasket or a loose mount. Swap it when the unit is near the ten-year mark, the housing has cracked, or the motor won't start after a reset. A new mid-range unit often costs about what a serious repair does.
One published guide lists a typical disposal repair at $50 to $400, and a unit plus installation at $150 to $950, with most jobs landing between $400 and $500. That guide also quotes handyperson labor at $50 to $75 an hour and plumber labor as high as $150.
The wiring matters when you swap. Certain models cord into a socket inside the cabinet, while others are wired straight to a wall switch. If the electrical side needs work, expect an electrician in the picture, and ask the quote to say who is doing what. Our page on installing a garbage disposal covers that side in more depth.
When is a disposal past saving?
Late starts, a slow spin, a growl that wasn't there last year, odors that survive a deep clean, and a puddle that returns after you've dried the cabinet. Any one of those points to wear. Two or three together say the unit is finished and a repair will only buy you months.
Check the leak source before blaming the machine. Water at the top flange is a failed seal. Water along the side seam means the housing itself is cracked and the unit has to go. Water at the discharge elbow or the dishwasher hose is a loose clamp, which is cheap. Our walk-through for a pipe leaking beneath the sink shows how to trace the drip.
Repeated clogs downstream aren't always the disposal's fault either. If the sink backs up even with the disposal off, the issue is the drain line, and our notes on a clogged kitchen sink drain apply. A jammed disposal that backs up gets its own steps.
Why do disposal quotes vary so much?
The rough guide runs $50 to $400 for a repair and $150 to $950 for a new disposal with labor, depending on motor size and the work around it. Greater horsepower, a new switch, fresh plumbing under the sink and a tight cabinet each push the figure up. Cheap parts help; awkward access doesn't.
Motor size is the largest lever. The same guide prices a 1/3 horsepower unit at $75 to $150, a 3/4 horsepower at $100 to $250, a 1 horsepower at $200 to $500 and a 2 horsepower at $300 to $1,000. Models that run on a wall switch units come in cheaper than batch-feed units.
Those numbers describe the whole country. Treat all of this as orientation. What a local plumber writes down after seeing your sink and wiring is the real price.
Does shower work fall under the same visit?
Yes. The usual shower calls are a dripping spout, a handle that won't shut off, water that seeps behind the wall, and flow that has faded. Mixing-valve cartridges, diverters and showerheads are the parts involved, and one look usually shows whether it's a part or something inside the wall.
Start with the head. Hard water scale clogs the little nozzles, and Ontario's 2025 utility report lists hardness averaging 91 to 177 ppm depending on the source, so deposits are a fair guess. Heads carrying the WaterSense label must stay at or below 2.0 gpm, and they're tested to hold their spray as pressure varies.
For leaks, see shower leak repair. For weak flow, see low shower pressure. A drip at the faucet side has its own leaky faucet guide, and fitting a new fixture is priced under faucet installation cost.
Common questions
Is this a same-hour fix?
A stuck plate or a reset is typically wrapped up inside an hour at the sink. Replacing the unit stretches to an hour or two, longer if the old mount won't release or the wiring needs changes. Tell us the age of the unit and whether it is hard-wired, and the quote can say what to expect.
What should I ask up front?
Find out the trip charge, whether it's credited when you go ahead, who takes the electrical side, what the written quote lists, and what happens if the cabinet plumbing needs changes. Bigger jobs raise a legal point as well: at $1,000 in parts and labor the state wants a contractor license on the work.
Must I be there while it's done?
Plan on an adult being present to open up and agree the price. From there the work happens inside one small cabinet, so you needn't watch. Empty the cabinet beforehand, and keep dogs elsewhere. If nobody can be there, say so when booking.
Is it safe to put my hand in a stuck disposal?
No. Turn off the switch, and for added safety unplug it or flip its breaker, before you reach into the opening. Use tongs or pliers to lift out whatever is stuck. Never use the disposal switch as a guide that the motor is off, because a jam can release and spin the blades.
Can a handyman install a new disposal?
Often. A handyperson can mount a plug-in unit and reconnect the drain, and this Old House lists handyperson labor at $50 to $75 an hour. Hard-wired units and any change to wiring or drain lines belong with a plumber or an electrician; have the quote state who does which part.